Are Security Careers Real?
-
@scottalanmiller said:
@IRJ said:
On paper, maybe they do. If you are in IT you have been dealing with security your whole career. It is just part of the job.
Exactly, I've almost never encountered a pure security role. When I have (including being the hiring manager for forty six figure and seven figure security positions) they were never "security" people, but just good IT people. If someone's focus is security, I assume they didn't have time to do IT, which means they can't do security. Catch-22. It's just good IT people that you need for security. When global security teams from Fortune 20 security consultancies go looking for seven figure security people, they don't look for any cert at all. They look for skilled, experienced people.
I am sure it doesn't hurt to add it to my list of certs. I still need my boss to approve one of my courses.
-
Following up on this... eight months later and I continue to talk to people who want to, are studying for or are looking for work in security, especially in "ethical hacking." Yes, not one has told me that they found work yet. Maybe some have and not mentioned it, but as this seems to represent more than 50% of all people going into tech jobs, it would logically represent a lot of hiring if it existed.
Anyone know anyone who has gotten work in this area?
-
I know one.
-
@Carnival-Boy said in Are Security Careers Real?:
I know one.
Any details? What kind of security job was it? What level? Did he search long? Was he a newbie or heavily experienced?
-
No, it was a guy that used to work for our MSP who was really in to security, and I got told one day he quit the MSP and got a job for a security firm in the City. Dunno more than that.
-
@Carnival-Boy said in Are Security Careers Real?:
No, it was a guy that used to work for our MSP who was really in to security, and I got told one day he quit the MSP and got a job for a security firm in the City. Dunno more than that.
Oh okay. Well, it's something.
I've known one or two people in security jobs so we can extrapolate that at some point they were hired into those jobs. But it was very few people and the jobs never seem to turn over.
-
Well from what I've seen with the IT Security people I've dealt with so far, you just need to be able to read a PDF of rules/guidelines and then tell the people who actually build and administer the stuff what they are and aren't allowed to do. But purely based off of that PDF or document, and with no rational thinking.
These security people were not previously real IT, but are just IT Security.
-
@Guest said in Are Security Careers Real?:
@scottalanmiller said:
Everyone and their brother is a "security expert" today. All of them working at McDonalds.
Or a computer repair shop but, the pay is likely about the same.
Nah, Mc****alds pays way more.
-
I've seen contracted IT work for 6-month terms but nothing full-time. I think Chase hires a lot of them. I'm sure some other banks do as well.
-
@wirestyle22 said in Are Security Careers Real?:
I've seen contracted IT work for 6-month terms but nothing full-time. I think Chase hires a lot of them. I'm sure some other banks do as well.
What kinds of positions? Having worked for those big banks, it's extremely rare. I've seen zero of that internally.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Are Security Careers Real?:
@wirestyle22 said in Are Security Careers Real?:
I've seen contracted IT work for 6-month terms but nothing full-time. I think Chase hires a lot of them. I'm sure some other banks do as well.
What kinds of positions? Having worked for those big banks, it's extremely rare. I've seen zero of that internally.
Security Analyst I, II, III etc. Auditing essentially.
-
@wirestyle22 said in Are Security Careers Real?:
@scottalanmiller said in Are Security Careers Real?:
@wirestyle22 said in Are Security Careers Real?:
I've seen contracted IT work for 6-month terms but nothing full-time. I think Chase hires a lot of them. I'm sure some other banks do as well.
What kinds of positions? Having worked for those big banks, it's extremely rare. I've seen zero of that internally.
Security Analyst I, II, III etc. Auditing essentially.
Okay, we don't generally consider those to be security OR IT jobs. That would explain it. Yes, I've seen tons of those in the banks. They are secretarial level jobs. The people doing them literally don't know how anything works. We would get questions like "why do we use SSH" or "can we prove Active Directory is useful."
Those are actually great examples of my point.... they appear to be security and/or IT jobs until you actually look and realize that are not actually a part of either discipline (normally.) Auditors are low cost, untrained people who do reports for checkmarking insurance or similar requirements. They are actually enemies to the security team. We've had the auditors try to have us disable security systems before.
-
The IT Security field has blown up recently and yes you can definitely make a career out of security and not be an auditor. I did learn that there are IT security people who essentially Auditors and then you have people like me that do hacking and penetration testing. Penetration Testing takes real skills and real knowledge of various Operating Systems, network devices, and protocols.
-
There is a program called CyberPatriot that is teaching kids in middle and high school cyber security. The idea behind this is that we are not creating the correct IT workforce needed to fill these jobs or so the people pitching the program (and LAUSD) say. I would love to hear @scottalanmiller talk to them about what he has seen in the industry.
-
@SamieWalters said in Are Security Careers Real?:
There is a program called CyberPatriot that is teaching kids in middle and high school cyber security. The idea behind this is that we are not creating the correct IT workforce needed to fill these jobs or so the people pitching the program (and LAUSD) say. I would love to hear @scottalanmiller talk to them about what he has seen in the industry.
I think that security training is awesome and that we need tons more of that. But that it needs to be something that everyone does rather than making loads of specific roles around it. As long as security is something that "someone else" does, we won't be very secure.
-
A co-worker stopped me this morning to tell me that her relative who works at local finance place is requiring their HR people to give their usernames/passwords to all of the other HR members so "things can get done" when they are not in the office. Total fail.
I wanna say she said it was Ameritrade, but I could be wrong.
-
@Dashrender said in Are Security Careers Real?:
A co-worker stopped me this morning to tell me that her relative who works at local finance place is requiring their HR people to give their usernames/passwords to all of the other HR members so "things can get done" when they are not in the office. Total fail.
I wanna say she said it was Ameritrade, but I could be wrong.
Wow wow wow. That's SEC violations right here. And privacy violations if HR is being compromised.
-
@Dashrender said in Are Security Careers Real?:
A co-worker stopped me this morning to tell me that her relative who works at local finance place is requiring their HR people to give their usernames/passwords to all of the other HR members so "things can get done" when they are not in the office. Total fail.
I wanna say she said it was Ameritrade, but I could be wrong.
I've dealt with similar, where HR wanted to GIVE me their passwords so I could just login and take care of things when they were at meetings.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Are Security Careers Real?:
@Dashrender said in Are Security Careers Real?:
A co-worker stopped me this morning to tell me that her relative who works at local finance place is requiring their HR people to give their usernames/passwords to all of the other HR members so "things can get done" when they are not in the office. Total fail.
I wanna say she said it was Ameritrade, but I could be wrong.
Wow wow wow. That's SEC violations right here. And privacy violations if HR is being compromised.
To make matters worse, the employee got reprimanded because of stuff done under her logon while she was out on vacation/leave/maternity leave.
-
@Dashrender said in Are Security Careers Real?:
@scottalanmiller said in Are Security Careers Real?:
@Dashrender said in Are Security Careers Real?:
A co-worker stopped me this morning to tell me that her relative who works at local finance place is requiring their HR people to give their usernames/passwords to all of the other HR members so "things can get done" when they are not in the office. Total fail.
I wanna say she said it was Ameritrade, but I could be wrong.
Wow wow wow. That's SEC violations right here. And privacy violations if HR is being compromised.
To make matters worse, the employee got reprimanded because of stuff done under her logon while she was out on vacation/leave/maternity leave.
Which is an identify theft problem.
